![]() In turn, Gattellari used his sidekick Senad Kaminic to pay the actual hitman, Haissam Safetli. Gattellari, who pleaded guilty to his role in the murder, told the jury that he had organised the murder at the instigation of his patron, Medich, and that the wealthy businessman provided large sums of money to secure both McGurk’s murder and the later intimidation of his wife. He said Gattellari’s subsequent conviction for trying to extort money from Medich, using the services of now-convicted murderers Roger Rogerson and Glen McNamara, showed Gattellari’s “capacity for deceit and a peculiar tendency to shift blame to others by layers of unsupportable, and at times unintelligible and irrational accusation.” “Shorn of any corroboration, Gattellari simply was not a credible witness,” said Mr Walker in his written submissions. Brett Anderson Walker’s new book The Killing Name is a breathtaking thriller that delves into the mayhem and mystery of love and murder. Medich’s barrister Bret Walker, SC, had argued that the jury returned an unreasonable verdict on both counts after Gattellari “gave contradictory and wholly inadequate evidence on what are contended to be critical facts”.īecause of the number of “errors and irregularities”, which he claimed had occurred throughout the trial, Mr Walker last year told the CCA there had been a “substantial miscarriage of justice” and he was seeking an acquittal rather than a retrial.Ĭentral to Mr Walker’s proposition that the verdicts were “unsafe and unsatisfactory” was the unreliability of the Crown’s star witness, Gattellari. In their majority decision, judges Bathurst and Hoeben rejected Medich’s bid to have his conviction quashed. “However, I do not think that that amounted to a substantial miscarriage of justice,” he said. A Lexington County jury could have given Brett Hollis the death penalty for murders of his ex- girlfriends mother and boyfriend. More posts you may like Noir cyberpunk zombie apocalypse, according to AI All My Sons (1948) Film Noir Starring Edward G. In his dissenting judgment, Justice Hamill said that “in spite of the weaknesses in Gattellari’s evidence” the case against Medich was a strong one and therefore he should not be acquitted but instead be granted a re-trial.Ĭhief Justice Bathurst agreed that certain evidence of Gattellari’s sidekick Senad Kaminic was inadmissible. Justice Hamill found that a “combination of errors” impacted the fairness of Medich’s trial and resulted in a “substantial miscarriage of justice.” Even with the help of his best friend, Captain Pierre Lamont of the Paris Homicide Department, it will require stealth and a lot of luck to clear him and. ![]() He said that while the evidence of Gattellari “was riddled with problems” and was “dubious and unimpressive” it was not the only evidence capable of implicating Medich in the murder of McGurk. In his dissenting judgment, Justice Peter Hamill said he agreed with Chief Justice Tom Bathurst that it was not unreasonable for the jury to have reached guilty verdicts for the murder of McGurk and the later intimidation of Mrs McGurk.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |